FC2ブログ

History Channel の護教番組 "The Exodus Decoded":モーゼが神に会ったシナイ山は現在の Hashem el Tarif 山だ。

はじめに


・ 2006-04-16 に放映された TV ドキュメンタリー、


The Exodus Decoded is a documentary film aired April 16, 2006 on The History Channel. The program was created by Israeli-Canadian filmmaker Simcha Jacobovici and producer/director James Cameron. (The two would later work together on The Lost Tomb of Jesus.) The documentary explores the supposed evidence for the Biblical account of the Exodus. Its claims and methods were criticized by Biblical scholars and mainstream scientists.

ref: The Exodus Decoded - Wikipedia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Exodus_Decoded


 から。

抜粋(デタラメ)


・1:19:00 旧約聖書に記載されたシナイ山とは現在の Hashem el Tarif だ。その根拠は…(略)

・200m 程度の高さ。山頂で水が出る。


prof. uzi avner arava environmental institute, israel

20200224_mt.jpg

20200224_mt2.jpg

ドキュメンタリー動画(1:34:40)


・The Exodus Decoded | Feature Documentary
115,403 views,Feb 9, 2019


批判


・タイトルの主張に対し、以下のような批判がなされていると…


Criticisms

The hypothesis that this mountain is the original Mount Sinai has faced criticism.[3] Some of the arguments against the proposal that Hashem El Tarif is Mount Sinai are as follows:

1. There is no mention in history of Hashem El Tarif, nor any well-known local tradition pointing to it as Mount Sinai.

2. There is no widespread Rabbinic-era Jewish tradition about the location of Mount Sinai. It does not seem to have been an important part of Jewish identity, and was a more distinctly Christian phenomenon.[4] (Dr. Kerkeslager does state that there is evidence of early Christian traditions for Mount Sinai in northwestern Saudi Arabia at Jabal al-Lawz and Jabal Maqla, though).

3. As a part of the greater criticism of the Peninsula location for Mount Sinai, another criticism is that the Peninsula was likely controlled by the ancient Egyptian Empire at the time of the Exodus, with garrisons being placed throughout the Peninsula to protect the valuable copper and turquoise mines.[5] Further, according to the book of Exodus, Moses came to Mount Sinai at the burning bush when he still resided in Midian. The land of Midian is largely recognized as the northwest portion of modern Saudi Arabia.

ref: Hashem El Tarif - Wikipedia - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashem_El_Tarif


(2020-02-24)
関連記事

コメントの投稿

非公開コメント

プロフィール

横着者 (ご連絡はコメント欄にて)

Author:横着者 (ご連絡はコメント欄にて)

最新記事
最新コメント
最新トラックバック
月別アーカイブ
カテゴリ
検索フォーム
RSSリンクの表示
リンク
ブロとも申請フォーム

この人とブロともになる

QRコード
QR